Best Catchers Mitt For High School Baseball Review Reviews in 2022 [Expert Picks]

*Disclaimer: TheSwingConnection.Com earns a commission from qualifying purchases without extra cost from customers.

List of Content Inside show

Things to Consider Before Buying a Catcher’s Mitt

Right Hand Throw vs. Left Hand Throw Mitt

Purchasing both kinds of mitts is available via online retailers such as Amazon (Left Hand Mitt and Right Hand Mitt).
On the other hand, buyers sometimes get confused and end up purchasing a glove for the wrong hand. As a result, you should use caution in this regard.
Now, the issue is, what do you do?

Our Top 3 Picks


- 25%
#Top 1
SWINGRAIL Baseball/Softball Swing Trainer
Amazon.com
SWINGRAIL Baseball/Softball Swing Trainer
$29.99 $39.99 
- 13%
#Top 2
Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove - Field Master - Baseball and Softball Mitt , 12" - Trapeze Web, Tan
Amazon.com
Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove - Field Master - Baseball and...
$18.99 $21.99 
- 19%
#Top 3
Franklin Sports Teeball Glove - Left and Right Handed Youth Fielding Glove - Meshtek Series - Synthetic Leather Baseball Glove - Ready To Play Glove - 9.5 Inch Right Hand Throw with Ball - Navy/Lime/Orange
Amazon.com
Franklin Sports Teeball Glove - Left and Right Handed Youth Fielding Glove -...
$16.03 $19.99 

10 Top Picks of Catchers Mitt For High School Baseball

1
SWINGRAIL Baseball/Softball Swing Trainer
Best choice
SWINGRAIL Baseball/Softball Swing Trainer
Check Price Amazon.com
9.8
2
Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove - Field Master - Baseball and Softball Mitt , 12" - Trapeze Web, Tan
Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove - Field Master - Baseball and Softball Mitt , 12" -...
Check Price Amazon.com
9.5
3
Franklin Sports Teeball Glove - Left and Right Handed Youth Fielding Glove - Meshtek Series - Synthetic Leather Baseball Glove - Ready To Play Glove - 9.5 Inch Right Hand Throw with Ball - Navy/Lime/Orange
Franklin Sports Teeball Glove - Left and Right Handed Youth Fielding Glove - Meshtek Series -...
Check Price Amazon.com
9
4
EASTON E610CBP Catchers Bat & Equipment Backpack Bag, Black, 2021, Baseball Softball, Vented All Gear Compartment, 2 Bat Sleeves, Internal Shelf, Vented Shoe Pocket, Mesh Leg Guard Sleeves
EASTON E610CBP Catchers Bat & Equipment Backpack Bag, Black, 2021, Baseball Softball, Vented All...
Check Price Amazon.com
8.7
5
Rawlings Official League Recreational Grade OLB3/R8U Baseballs, Bucket of 24 Balls, OLB3BUCK24
Rawlings Official League Recreational Grade OLB3/R8U Baseballs, Bucket of 24 Balls, OLB3BUCK24
Check Price Amazon.com
8
6
Rawlings Player Preferred Baseball Catcher's Mitt, Regular, 1-Piece Solid Web, 33 Inch
Rawlings Player Preferred Baseball Catcher's Mitt, Regular, 1-Piece Solid Web, 33 Inch
Check Price Amazon.com
7.7
7
SKLZ Soft Cushioned Safety Baseballs, 2 Pack
SKLZ Soft Cushioned Safety Baseballs, 2 Pack
Check Price Amazon.com
7.6
8
Rawlings High School Level, R100-P Practice Baseballs, Box of 12 Balls
Rawlings High School Level, R100-P Practice Baseballs, Box of 12 Balls
Check Price Amazon.com
7.3
9
Rawlings Sandlot Series Leather Modified Trap-Eze Web Baseball Glove, 11-3/4", Right Hand Throw
Rawlings Sandlot Series Leather Modified Trap-Eze Web Baseball Glove, 11-3/4", Right Hand Throw
Check Price Amazon.com
7
10
Wilson A500 32" Catcher's Mitt - Right Hand Throw
Wilson A500 32" Catcher's Mitt - Right Hand Throw
Check Price Amazon.com
6.9

Best Catchers Mitt For High School Baseball Products Features & Details

SWINGRAIL Baseball/Softball Swing Trainer

SWINGRAIL Baseball/Softball Swing Trainer

Important Features of The Product:

  • THE SIMPLE WAY TO IMPROVE YOUR SWING MECHANICS & BECOME A BETTER HITTER!
  • INNOVATIVE TRAINING AID ALLOWS PLAYERS TO “FEEL” HOW TO SWING CORRECTLY; Trains Players to Develop Proper Muscle Memory for "Live" Hitting in Games
  • CORRECTS SIX COMMON HITTING MISTAKES; Breakaway Guidestrap Provides Immediate Feedback When the Player Swings Incorrectly
  • USED BY MORE THAN 250,000 PLAYERS FROM AGES 9 TO PROFESSIONAL; Winner of Collegiate Baseball’s “Best of Show” Award at the American Baseball Coaches Association convention
  • INCLUDES 15 ONLINE INSTRUCTIONAL VIDEOS & TRAINING PROGRAM; “SWINGRAIL Helps me stay inside and take a great path to the ball”, CODY BELLINGER

Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove - Field Master - Baseball and Softball Mitt , 12" - Trapeze Web, Tan

Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove - Field Master - Baseball and Softball Mitt , 12" - Trapeze Web, Tan

Important Features of The Product:

  • Easy break in: The soft synthetic leather material is lightweight and responsive making the glove easy and quick to break in so it will be game ready in no time for baseball, softball, or teeball
  • Adjustable: Complete with an adjustable wrist strap and contour fit system for a customizable thumb adjustment, this glove is designed to fit all players comfortably according to their preferences
  • Durablility: Crafted of a thick, premium synthetic leather designed to mimic the performance and durability of a true leather mitt without the long break in period
  • Hand formed pocket: The hand formed pocket provides maximum comfort and responsive feel for making scoops and catches without drops
  • Note: Left hand thrower glove = worn on right hand to throw with left; Right hand throw = glove worn on left hand to throw with right

Franklin Sports Teeball Glove - Left and Right Handed Youth Fielding Glove - Meshtek Series - Synthetic Leather Baseball Glove - Ready To Play Glove - 9.5 Inch Right Hand Throw with Ball - Navy/Lime/Orange

Franklin Sports Teeball Glove - Left and Right Handed Youth Fielding Glove - Meshtek Series - Synthetic Leather Baseball Glove - Ready To Play Glove - 9.5 Inch Right Hand Throw with Ball - Navy/Lime/Orange

Important Features of The Product:

  • Soft and lightweight: The lightweight, soft mesh construction makes this glove easy to use for younger players
  • Ready to play: The soft palm construction means there is no need to break inch This glove comes all ready to play
  • Hand formed pocket: The glove pocket is designed specifically to the contours of a kids hand for an easy comfortable fit
  • Ball included: This combo set includes a soft foam ball so you have everything you need for playing indoors or out
  • Note: Left Hand Thrower glove = worn on right hand to throw with left; Right Hand Throw = glove worn on left hand to throw with right

EASTON E610CBP Catchers Bat & Equipment Backpack Bag, Black, 2021, Baseball Softball, Vented All Gear Compartment, 2 Bat Sleeves, Internal Shelf, Vented Shoe Pocket, Mesh Leg Guard Sleeves

EASTON E610CBP Catchers Bat & Equipment Backpack Bag, Black, 2021, Baseball Softball, Vented All Gear Compartment, 2 Bat Sleeves, Internal Shelf, Vented Shoe Pocket, Mesh Leg Guard Sleeves

Important Features of The Product:

  • Built to hold all of your catcher's gear and then some
  • Features a Vented main compartment to fit catcher's gear with an interior shelf
  • External strap and buckle on the front

Rawlings Official League Recreational Grade OLB3/R8U Baseballs, Bucket of 24 Balls, OLB3BUCK24

Rawlings Official League Recreational Grade OLB3/R8U Baseballs, Bucket of 24 Balls, OLB3BUCK24

Important Features of The Product:

  • 24 Opounds3 and R8U Baseballs in a bucket for easy transport
  • Ideal for players ages 8 and under
  • May contain Opounds3 or r8u baseballs, which are materially the same and only different in name
  • Easy to grip and throw due to synthetic leather covers with solid cork and rubber centers
  • Durable white bucket includes mpounds logo and red rawlings patch
  • The number one choice of leagues, coaches, parents, and players in North America

Rawlings Player Preferred Baseball Catcher's Mitt, Regular, 1-Piece Solid Web, 33 Inch

Rawlings Player Preferred Baseball Catcher's Mitt, Regular, 1-Piece Solid Web, 33 Inch

Important Features of The Product:

  • 33 inch baseball catcher's mitt great for recreational baseball and Softball games
  • Zero Shock palm padding for increased impact Protection while catching
  • Quick and Easy break in for a game Ready feel
  • Conventional back for a secure fit
  • 1 piece solid web Designed for catchers
  • Right Hand Throw = Left Hand Glove, Left Hand Throw = Right Hand Glove
  • Right Hand Orientation = Right Hand Throw / Left Hand Orientation = Left Hand Throw

SKLZ Soft Cushioned Safety Baseballs, 2 Pack

SKLZ Soft Cushioned Safety Baseballs, 2 Pack

Important Features of The Product:

  • Reduced impact training balls provide an authentic baseball look with soft, cushioned construction
  • Helps youth players build confidence by reducing fear about impact
  • Same size and visual cues as standard baseballs for effective training
  • Comes with 2 Safety Balls
  • Standard baseball circumference of 9 inches

Rawlings High School Level, R100-P Practice Baseballs, Box of 12 Balls

Rawlings High School Level, R100-P Practice Baseballs, Box of 12 Balls

Important Features of The Product:

  • Ideal for players in high school and youth leagues, ages 18 under
  • Suitable for practice use
  • Improved grip with rawlings' raised seam stitching
  • Cushioned cork center, standard windings, and core bond adhesive
  • Enhanced durability with full-grain leather cover.comes with 12 (1 dozen) r100-p balls in a box.official size and weight (9 inch circumference, 5 oz. ).Included components: Baseballs / Softball

Rawlings Sandlot Series Leather Modified Trap-Eze Web Baseball Glove, 11-3/4", Right Hand Throw

Rawlings Sandlot Series Leather Modified Trap-Eze Web Baseball Glove, 11-3/4", Right Hand Throw

Important Features of The Product:

  • 11 3/4 inch baseball glove for men crafted from full grain, oiled leather for a vintage look
  • Zero shock palm pads protect your hands
  • Padded finger back lining ensures superior comfort
  • Ready to play, comes 90 percent broken in from the factory
  • Available in a wide range of glove lengths and web styles
  • Right hand throw is equal to left hand glove, left hand throw is equal to right hand glove
  • Right Hand Orientation = Right Hand Throw / Left Hand Orientation = Left Hand Throw
  • Sport type: Baseball and Softball

Wilson A500 32" Catcher's Mitt - Right Hand Throw

Wilson A500 32" Catcher's Mitt - Right Hand Throw

Important Features of The Product:

  • 32" catcher's mitt
  • Half moon web
  • Black/Copper top grain leather
  • Rolled dual welting
  • Double palm construction

How to tell if the mitt is for the left hand or right hand?

The main e-commerce websites clearly state if a particular glove is for the “Left Hand” or the “Right Hand,” respectively.
On Amazon, you’ll see that most people refer to it as a “Left Hand Throw” or a “Right Hand Throw,” respectively.
The player who throws the ball with his left hand is known as the “Left Hand Throw,” He will need a glove for his right hand to do it.
Throw with the right hand: The term “Right Hand Throw” refers to a player who throws a ball using his right hand, and as a result, he will need a glove for his left hand to do so.
So, if you throw a ball with your left hand, you’ll need a glove that says “Left Hand Throw,” “Right Hand Glove,” “LHT,” and “RHG,” among other abbreviations.
When throwing with the right hand, you’ll need a mitt labeled “Right Hand Throw,” “Left Hand Glove,” “Right Hand Throw,” and “Left Hand Glove” in addition to the standard “Right Hand Throw.”

Easy to Break-In

It is essential that your new catcher’s mitt is simple to break in.
If you go into a store and the shopkeeper attempts to sell you a baseball glove by claiming that you don’t need break-in, he lies to you.
Regardless of whether you are getting a 350-dollar catcher’s mitt or a 45-dollar glove, there is just a minimal amount of breaking in required.
Because the firm has already completed some work on the property, the break-in period may be reduced. However, if someone asserts that there is no need for a break-in, this is not accurate in this case.
As a result, if your mitt is simple to break in, the glove will change rapidly to your hand’s shape. Otherwise, you may have to experiment with other breaking techniques in the mitt.
However, after the mitt has been broken in, it has little effect on its performance.
Consequently, it is false to assert that a glove that is easier to break in would provide more excellent performance when compared to other mitts that need more time to break-in.
You may learn more about how to break in a glove by watching the video below. You may also check out this video, which goes through the process of breaking in mitts.

Softball vs. Baseball Catcher’s Glove

There is a slight variation in size between a baseball mitt and a softball glove.
Because softball is more significant than baseball, softball mitts feature deeper pockets and thinner sides to catch the ball. 
As a result, do not purchase a softball mitt under the impression that the two sports are equivalent. This oversight may have an impact on your performance. As a result, it will be beneficial to learn all there is to know about the differences between baseball gloves and softball gloves. 

Leather Quality of Mitt

It is important to note that the quality of the leather is a crucial element in determining the price of a glove.
Most of the time, the low-cost mitts are constructed of synthetic leather or pigskin leather. As a result, they are soft and not very durable.
Premium gloves and mittens are manufactured from high-quality leather, sourced from steer hides or exotic animals, whereas lower-priced gloves and mitts are created from cheaper leather.
The leather quality impacts how many seasons your glove will endure, so keep this in mind when choosing yours.
Please do not consider this to mean that the low-cost leather mitts will hinder your ability to perform.
The only difference between the two mitts is the leather quality, which determines how long they will last.
For young players, leather quality is not a significant factor in their decision.
Because of the longevity of a $300 baseball catcher’s glove, it is possible that a 12-year-old baseball catcher will not be able to use it for the following 2 to 3 years. At this age, the body expands, and he will want another glove after one or two years.
As a result, in my view, there is no need to spend on high-quality leather mitts for youngsters since you will have to replace them after a short period.
If you can afford it, go ahead and get it; your kid or daughter will adore that mitt!

Pocket Area of the Mitt

Your glove should produce a functional pocket that can hold a baseball that is coming at you quickly.
It becomes much easier to catch and control the ball when the pocket area is of the proper size and shape.
Consequently, if you are shopping for a baseball glove at a sporting goods store, pay particular attention to the pocket region of the mitt before making a purchase.
If the pocket area is too small, it may not be easy to grab and retain the balls in the pocket region. On the other hand, a deep pocket provides you with comfort while also allowing you to capture and keep the ball in your glove more swiftly.
As a result, catchers should go for mitts with a large pocket for their hands.

Mitts with Adjustable Strap

Some catcher’s mitts come with an adjustable strap, while others do not.
This strap is quite helpful for tightening or loosening the mitt.
However, you will not find it in most mitts and gloves since it is not essential.
Your glove includes an adjustable strap, which is beneficial and provides you with even another incentive to choose a specific mitt.
However, it is not a deal-breaker in this case.
As a result, you should not rule out a high-quality mitt just because it does not include an adjustable wrist strap.
There are relatively few mitts that have an adjustable strap, and those that do are pretty rare.
Yes, it may be beneficial for some players, but it is not required for most players.
Take a look at the Wilson A360 Youth Catcher’s Mitt if you’re looking for a budget-friendly option that has an adjustable strap.
While, if you’re looking for a high-priced catcher’s glove with an adjustable strap, check out the All-Star Pro Elite CM3000SBT Catcher’s Mitt from Major League Baseball.
If you want to learn more about the All-Star Pro CM3000SBT Mitt, you should check out my other post, which is titled “All-Star Pro CM3000SBT Review.”

Padding

The correct quantity of padding should be used in the catcher’s glove to absorb shock effectively. But, at the same time, you should be able to catch the balls with relative ease as well.
However, some infield players favor super-skin models with shallow pockets depending on the position.
To do this, you’ll need a glove with the appropriate amount of padding to cushion the shock of rapidly approaching pitches.

Looks

This varies from one to individual.
Some catchers like dark-colored gloves, but others prefer light-colored mitts.
You should consider one thing before purchasing a glove in this situation: occasionally, individuals purchase mitts based only on their looks.
Although the aesthetic of the glove is significant, the performance of the glove is more vital than its appearance.
Almost all of the gloves are attractive, in my opinion. Just make sure you give it the attention it deserves and cleans it from time to time.

FAQ

What size catcher’s mitt good for high school?

The most common size of the catcher’s mitt for any child in High School age is between 32.5 to 34 inches. Some children prefer a large glove with a larger catching surface, and some prefer a small mitt for a quicker ball transfer. On the other hand, for 13 to 14 years old children, a 32-inch catcher mitt can be the right choice.

What size catcher’s mitt good for the youth?

When it comes to the development of young baseball catchers, it is often dependent on their ability to demand their defensive standing and gain the confidence of their pitchers.
The ability of the catcher to receive the ball has a significant influence on the outcome of every game in which they participate. Children between the ages of 8 and 10 years old often use a 30 to 31 inches long glove. Children between the ages of 11 and 13 years old, on the other hand, may wear mitts with a circumference of 30 to 32 inches.

How to Measure Size of a Catcher’s Mitt?

Because the mitt does not have distinct fingers, it is distinguished from a baseball glove in many ways, including its size and shape. The mitts have been created in a particular manner to handle wild pitches more efficiently than any other outfielder’s glove.
Because the structure of the mitt differs from that of the glove, a new method of determining the appropriate size is necessary for the mitt. The circumference of the catcher’s glove is measured, and it may vary from 31 to 34 12 inches. Standard mitts from the most well-known brands are measured in this manner. You may need to have a more personalized glove made to acquire a more exact size.

Final Words

It should be noted that these are not the only mitts available on the market.
There are also several more excellent catching mitts that you may experiment with and eventually acquire since you will not be a competent catcher until you have one of them.
Even better, it would help if you experimented with a different mitt this year to see how it goes. In the year 2021, there are a plethora of excellent possibilities.
However, while making a purchase, keep in mind that a high-priced mitt will survive for a few years due to the high-quality leather used in its construction. You may also want to consider purchasing a glove that will aid you in detecting signals.
To avoid spending a large amount of money on catchers gloves for high school baseball, you might consider purchasing a pair that will last longer than the first one.
However, it would help if you kept in mind that the high-priced glove will take some time to break in. You can’t expect both the high-priced and low-cost gloves to break-in at the same rate, nor can you expect them to.
The other elements, such as the design and the ability to adapt, are essential, but they are not deal-breakers in and of themselves.

I hope you could find some helpful information and learn more about some of the top catcher’s mitts for high school baseball players in 2021 that these young athletes can utilize.
Feel free to ask any questions in the comments area if you have any. I’ll make every effort to respond as quickly as possible.