Best Quality Softball Gloves Reviews in 2022 [Top Picks]

*Disclaimer: TheSwingConnection.Com earns a commission from qualifying purchases without extra cost from customers.

List of Content Inside show

Buying Guide: How to Choose the Best Fastpitch Softball Glove?

Having gone through all of the most excellent fastpitch gloves available, I should teach you how to negotiate the dangerous marketing world to get the best fastpitch softball glove available. All that is required is that you establish a set of standards.
If the glove you’re considering can live up to the expectations, you’ll be in good shape. Because of this, I’m going to break this shopping advice into two parts: There are two types of considerations: A) primary considerations and B) secondary considerations. You’ll understand what I’m talking about after you’ve gone through them.

Our Top 3 Picks


- 14%
#Top 1
Baseball and Softball Batting Gloves | American Flag Style | Durable Quality Baseball Gear | Genuine Leather | Unisex Adult | Large
Amazon.com
Baseball and Softball Batting Gloves | American Flag Style | Durable Quality...
$29.99 $34.99 
#Top 2
Rawlings RLA125FS-15WNS-0/3 Liberty Advanced Left-Handed Fastpitch Softball Glove, White/Scarlet/Navy, 12.5
Amazon.com
Rawlings RLA125FS-15WNS-0/3 Liberty Advanced Left-Handed Fastpitch Softball...
$177.19
#Top 3
Spiderz USA Flag w/New Web Tac Grip Hybrid Baseball/Softball Batting Gloves w/Spider Web Grip and Protective Top Hand in Adult &Youth Sizes - Professional (PRO) Quality (Adult Large)
Amazon.com
Spiderz USA Flag w/New Web Tac Grip Hybrid Baseball/Softball Batting Gloves...
out of stock

Top 10 Best Quality Softball Gloves

1
Baseball and Softball Batting Gloves | American Flag Style | Durable Quality Baseball Gear | Genuine Leather | Unisex Adult | Large
Best choice
Baseball and Softball Batting Gloves | American Flag Style | Durable Quality Baseball Gear |...
Check Price Amazon.com
9.5
2
Rawlings RLA125FS-15WNS-0/3 Liberty Advanced Left-Handed Fastpitch Softball Glove, White/Scarlet/Navy, 12.5
Recommended
Rawlings RLA125FS-15WNS-0/3 Liberty Advanced Left-Handed Fastpitch Softball Glove,...
Check Price Amazon.com
9.2
3
Spiderz USA Flag w/New Web Tac Grip Hybrid Baseball/Softball Batting Gloves w/Spider Web Grip and Protective Top Hand in Adult &Youth Sizes - Professional (PRO) Quality (Adult Large)
Spiderz USA Flag w/New Web Tac Grip Hybrid Baseball/Softball Batting Gloves w/Spider Web Grip and...
Check Price Amazon.com
9.1
4
Spiderz USA Flag w/New Web Tac Grip Hybrid Baseball/Softball Batting Gloves w/Spider Web Grip and Protective Top Hand in Adult &Youth Sizes - Professional (PRO) Quality (Adult Small)
Spiderz USA Flag w/New Web Tac Grip Hybrid Baseball/Softball Batting Gloves w/Spider Web Grip and...
Check Price Amazon.com
8.8
5
Nike Women's Hyperdiamond Edge Batting Gloves 2019 (White/Black, Large)
Nike Women's Hyperdiamond Edge Batting Gloves 2019 (White/Black, Large)
Check Price Amazon.com
8.3
6
Rawlings Player Preferred Baseball Glove, Regular, Baseball/Softball Pattern, Basket-Web, 12-1/2 Inch
Rawlings Player Preferred Baseball Glove, Regular, Baseball/Softball Pattern, Basket-Web, 12-1/2...
Check Price Amazon.com
8.3
7
Mizuno GPSL1250F3 Prospect Select Series Fastpitch Softball Glove 12.5", Right Hand Throw, BLACK
Mizuno GPSL1250F3 Prospect Select Series Fastpitch Softball Glove 12.5", Right Hand Throw, BLACK
Check Price Amazon.com
8.1
8
Mizuno Womens MMX1205 Ball Park Softball Glove, Right Hand Throw, Black/Green, 12 Inches
Mizuno Womens MMX1205 Ball Park Softball Glove, Right Hand Throw, Black/Green, 12 Inches
Check Price Amazon.com
8.1
9
PHINIX 14" Slowpitch All Pigskin Softball Gloves (Tan & Brown)
PHINIX 14" Slowpitch All Pigskin Softball Gloves (Tan & Brown)
Check Price Amazon.com
8.1
10
Amazon Basics Adult Baseball Softball Equipment Backpack - 13.5 x 9.5 x 20 Inches, Blue
Amazon Basics Adult Baseball Softball Equipment Backpack - 13.5 x 9.5 x 20 Inches, Blue
Check Price Amazon.com
7.8

Every Products Detail of Best Quality Softball Gloves

Baseball and Softball Batting Gloves | American Flag Style | Durable Quality Baseball Gear | Genuine Leather | Unisex Adult | Large

Baseball and Softball Batting Gloves | American Flag Style | Durable Quality Baseball Gear | Genuine Leather | Unisex Adult | Large

Important Features of The Product:

  • RELAXED FIT - A flexible fabric backhand, together with a stretchy micro-fabric gusset finger lining allow for a comfort fit on your hands
  • COOL WEARING - Your hands remain cool and dry; A thumb mesh + finger vents + breathable micro-fabric finger lining promote air circulation
  • ENHANCED CONTROL and GRIP - Digitally embossed palm crafted from premium grade leather for great grip and feel of the bat
  • SECURE ADJUSTABLE CUFF - Our neoprene construction guarantees free wrist mobility. Adjustable cuff size with a velcro hook and loop design
  • BEAUTIFUL SUBLIMATION DESIGN - Live free and stand for your flag. Outstanding colors.

Rawlings RLA125FS-15WNS-0/3 Liberty Advanced Left-Handed Fastpitch Softball Glove, White/Scarlet/Navy, 12.5

Rawlings RLA125FS-15WNS-0/3 Liberty Advanced Left-Handed Fastpitch Softball Glove, White/Scarlet/Navy, 12.5

Important Features of The Product:

  • DESIGNED FOR PITCHERS, INFIELD, AND OUTFIELD PLAYERS, this Liberty Advanced 12. 5 inch fast pitch softball glove is perfect for a utility player who needs a glove that will break-in quickly and form a long-lasting pocket
  • IDEAL FOR AVID PLAYERS FROM HIGH SCHOOL TO THE PROS. Pattern: 125SB
  • QUALITY FULL-GRAIN LEATHER adds durability and a comfortable feel
  • PULL-STRAP CLOSURES allow each player to find the perfect fit to their hand
  • Right Hand Throw = Left Hand Glove, Left Hand Throw = Right Hand Glove
  • Right Hand Orientation = Right Hand Throw / Left Hand Orientation = Left Hand Throw

Spiderz USA Flag w/New Web Tac Grip Hybrid Baseball/Softball Batting Gloves w/Spider Web Grip and Protective Top Hand in Adult &Youth Sizes - Professional (PRO) Quality (Adult Large)

Spiderz USA Flag w/New Web Tac Grip Hybrid Baseball/Softball Batting Gloves w/Spider Web Grip and Protective Top Hand in Adult &Youth Sizes - Professional (PRO) Quality (Adult Large)

Important Features of The Product:

  • New Spiderz Web Tac Palm
  • Palm pad perfect those who drop fingers off the bat handle
  • Flex cut knuckles for better fit
  • Durable, triple reinforced wrist strap
  • Sold in pairs

Spiderz USA Flag w/New Web Tac Grip Hybrid Baseball/Softball Batting Gloves w/Spider Web Grip and Protective Top Hand in Adult &Youth Sizes - Professional (PRO) Quality (Adult Small)

Spiderz USA Flag w/New Web Tac Grip Hybrid Baseball/Softball Batting Gloves w/Spider Web Grip and Protective Top Hand in Adult &Youth Sizes - Professional (PRO) Quality (Adult Small)

Important Features of The Product:

  • New Spiderz Web Tac Palm
  • Palm pad perfect those who drop fingers off the bat handle
  • Flex cut knuckles for better fit
  • Durable, triple reinforced wrist strap
  • Sold in pairs

Nike Women's Hyperdiamond Edge Batting Gloves 2019 (White/Black, Large)

Nike Women's Hyperdiamond Edge Batting Gloves 2019 (White/Black, Large)

Important Features of The Product:

  • Reasonable Price
  • Best Quality Product

Rawlings Player Preferred Baseball Glove, Regular, Baseball/Softball Pattern, Basket-Web, 12-1/2 Inch

Rawlings Player Preferred Baseball Glove, Regular, Baseball/Softball Pattern, Basket-Web, 12-1/2 Inch

Important Features of The Product:

  • 12 1/2 INCH ADULT GLOVE | Perfect for recreational baseball and slowpitch softball
  • BASKET WEB | Versatile web that can be used at any position on the field
  • FULL GRAIN LEATHER | Quality material ensures enhanced durability
  • ZERO SHOCK PALM PADDING | Provides increased impact protection while catching
  • ADJUSTABLE WRIST STRAP | Allows for a customizable fit for maximum comfort
  • GAME READY FEEL | With quick, easy 80% factory - 20% player break-in process

Mizuno GPSL1250F3 Prospect Select Series Fastpitch Softball Glove 12.5", Right Hand Throw, BLACK

Mizuno GPSL1250F3 Prospect Select Series Fastpitch Softball Glove 12.5", Right Hand Throw, BLACK

Important Features of The Product:

  • Gender engineered: Mizuno engineering philosophy to maximize performance by tailoring products to meet the needs of the female athlete
  • Full grain leather shell: for great durability. Youth Ages : 10-12
  • Mzo lining: disperses perspiration away from the skin.
  • Polyurethane power lock: the simplest and most secure fit Available with PU pull tab.
  • Thumb cut: thumb area hinge to increases flexibility in order to make closing the glove easier.
  • Less 2 Lacing: Removes the last 2 lace loops on the web to increase flexibility along the closing axis.
  • Parashock Palm Pad: Mizuno's exclusive palm pad absorbs the shock of repeated use providing outstanding protection and ideal comfort
  • PowerClose Technology: Makes catching easy for younger players.

Mizuno Womens MMX1205 Ball Park Softball Glove, Right Hand Throw, Black/Green, 12 Inches

Mizuno Womens MMX1205 Ball Park Softball Glove, Right Hand Throw, Black/Green, 12 Inches

Important Features of The Product:

  • Full Grain Pigskin Leather Shell
  • PowerLock Wristband
  • Butter-Soft Lining
  • V-Flex for Easy Closure

PHINIX 14" Slowpitch All Pigskin Softball Gloves (Tan & Brown)

PHINIX 14" Slowpitch All Pigskin Softball Gloves (Tan & Brown)

Important Features of The Product:

  • MATERIAL: The gloves are made of advanced all pigskin shell + PU inner + PU lace, With a fleece lining that makes them comfortable to use.Fully customized high-quality Pigskin leather ensures a stunning look.
  • LIGHT-WEIGHT:Flexible amd light weight provide maximum comfort for players! PU palm lining and index finger pads add shock absorption. It offers great protection for the player’s hands while allowing the player to catch the ball effectively
  • EASY BREAK IN: The soft material is making the glove easy and quick to break in so it will be game ready in no time for baseball, softball.
  • ADJUSTABLE: Complete with an adjustable wrist strap for an easily adjustable fit
  • NOTE: Right Hand Throw = Left Right Hand Glove.Left Hand Throw = Right Hand Glove.

Amazon Basics Adult Baseball Softball Equipment Backpack - 13.5 x 9.5 x 20 Inches, Blue

Amazon Basics Adult Baseball Softball Equipment Backpack - 13.5 x 9.5 x 20 Inches, Blue

Important Features of The Product:

  • Baseball backpack for storing and carrying baseball gear to and from the field; made of high-quality ripstop reversed 600D polyester for reliable strength
  • Roomy main zipped compartment can hold a baseball helmet, batting gloves, a baseball cap, a catching glove, and more
  • Separate shoe compartment for cleats; 2 side pockets for a baseball bat and a water bottle (or 2 baseball bats); zipped front pocket for smaller items like keys, phone, etc.
  • Adjustable padded shoulder straps ensure comfort; integrated fence hook for hanging the backpack in the dugout
  • Measures 13.5 by 9.5 by 20 inches (LxWxH); blue with black accents; backed by an Amazon Basics 1-year limited warranty

Material Matters (Primary considerations)

When purchasing a softball glove, the first thing you should ask yourself is: what material is the glove composed of? When it comes to gloves, one single aspect may make the difference between selecting and rejecting the glove.
Gloves made of high-quality materials not only last longer but are also more pleasant to wear. They are also more durable. As a result, the glove’s fabric should be the first thing your eyes should inspect.
The majority of gloves will now be made of leather. As a result, you need to be aware of the differences to appreciate what each leather kind has to offer. I’ll give you a short rundown of the situation.

Steerhide

Thick and substantial. This leather will endure far longer than other leathers. However, because of this leather’s harsh character, it is difficult to break it in.
Cowhide/Rawhide: Cowhide/Rawhide is thinner than steer hide. On the other hand, the leather is supple, making it simpler to move about and a break-in.
Synthetic: The least desirable of the litter. Not as robust as cowhide or steerhide, but still enough. Gloves made of synthetic leather, on the other hand, are almost ready for action the minute they are taken out of the package.

Full-grain

Identical in appearance to steerhide, but thicker and more robust when compared to other varieties. Breaking into a glove made of full-grain leather, on the other hand, is a challenging task.
Top grain is a kind of grain that has a rounded shape. It is similar to cowhide in appearance but is thinner and more flexible, allowing players more freedom of movement. You do not have to exert much effort to break in the glove.
So you now have a clear image of what is going to happen. If you can spend a lot of money, full-grain steerhide gloves are a good investment. However, if you don’t know how to break in the glove properly, your purchase might be a waste of money.
Those on a tight budget should go for synthetic leather or cowhide as their material of choice. Synthetic leather or top-grain cowhide gloves are ideal choices for first-time skateboarders. It does not need the use of a professional-grade break-in. You may nonetheless take pleasure in the game and improve your abilities.

Ready for the Game

After you’ve evaluated the glove’s construction quality, you should consider whether or not the glove is game-ready. Is it possible that it isn’t, and if it is, how long does it take to attain peak performance?
Numerous high-end gloves are constructed of robust and durable leather. While the allegedly indestructible leather seems to be an excellent idea on paper, the work of breaking in the leather may be pretty tricky.
Not everyone has the tools necessary to carry out the break-in rituals required to ignite a glove. So, if you don’t have the financial resources to purchase oils and other materials to prime the glove, choose a glove that has been factory broken in.
The glove will be 50-80% ready without touching it because of the factory break-in. As a result, a few games should be sufficient to get everything back up and running correctly.
That’s why it’s critical to determine whether or not you’re prepared to go through the grueling break-in process. If you are not, you are aware of your options.

Price to Performance Ratio

Following your evaluation of the glove’s manufacturing quality, you should determine whether or not the glove is ready to be used in a game situation. Do you think it’s conceivable that it isn’t, and if it is, how long do you think it will take to reach full performance?
A large number of high-end gloves are made of tough and long-lasting leather. However, although the notion of unbreakable leather sounds impressive on paper, the actual process of breaking in the leather may be time-consuming and challenging.
Some specific talents and items are needed to carry out the break-in rituals necessary to ignite a glove that is unavailable to everyone. So, if you don’t have the financial means to acquire oils and other ingredients to prime the glove, choose instead a glove that has already been broken in at the manufacturing facility.
Because of the factory break-in, the glove will be 50-80% ready before you ever put it on your hands. Therefore, a few games should be sufficient to restore regular operation.
To decide whether or not you are prepared to go through the arduous break-in process, it is necessary to conduct an assessment. If you aren’t, you should be informed of your alternatives.

Size and Position Flexibility (Secondary considerations)

Given your familiarity with the subject matter, you’re probably aware that it’s uncommon to come across a glove series ideal for every position. In addition to infield, outfield, and pitcher, most of the glove series I’ve described can support a total of three parts.
As a result, please obtain a glove series that includes a catcher’s mitt.
Again, this is a minor concern and is by no means a deal-breaker in this case. Having several sizes that are appropriate for different situations helps you shop comfortably without switching tabs every few minutes.

Velcro Wrist Closure

I’ll keep it short. There are two widespread closures in softball gloves- the Velcro wrist closure and the leather pull-strap. The pull-strap is sturdier and will last longer. However, the Velcro closure gives you a ton of more adjustment options.

FAQ

This article addresses some of the most frequently asked questions concerning fastpitch softball gloves. If you want to learn more about these bad boys, look at this website.

What gloves do pro softball players use?

Wilson A2000 is a two-word description. Yes, it is the glove that professional softball players use. For more than a century, Wilson has been a leading producer in the softball and baseball industries. It’s no surprise that their top-of-the-line glove is being utilized in the majors.

Is Mizuno a good brand for softball gloves?

Mizuno is a company that caters to those on a tight budget. Their gloves aren’t as densely packed as those made by Wilson and Rawlings. However, these are excellent beginner gloves. Aside from that, they don’t make softball gloves specifically for men. All of their softball gloves are designed specifically for female players.

Can you use a fast-pitch softball glove for a slow-pitch?

The answer is both yes and no. You can use a fastpitch glove for slow-pitch softball as well. However, there are subtle differences. For instance, fastpitch catchers need gloves with thicker padding because of the high velocity of the ball. So, you can use both gloves interchangeably, but your performance can suffer.

What size glove do college softball players use?

The majority of collegiate softball players use gloves with a circumference of 12-14 inches. The length and breadth of a player’s hand may impact the game’s outcome.

Should you steam girls’ youth softball gloves?

It is possible to soften the glove by steaming it. There is, however, a snag in the plan. The leather’s durability will suffer as a result of this.

Are softball gloves bigger than baseball gloves?

Yes. It just must be. Softball balls are much more significant. As a result, the giant glove may accommodate the larger ball.

Wrapping Up

Fastpitch softball necessitates a high-octane level of performance. You must be on your toes at all times to prevent the batters from moving bases.
When it comes to your catching gloves, even the slightest discomfort might be the difference between winning and losing. That is why you want the most delicate fastpitch softball glove to get an advantage over your opponents. 
The gloves I’ve examined all can help you win crucial matches, provided you know how to use them properly and effectively. Nonetheless, I have a few faves from the collection.
Providing that you have the necessary funds, I strongly advise you to get the Wilson A2000. This glove is a one-time purchase of a certain kind. I’m referring to the fact that you can acquire it for your high school games. And, if you keep it up, you can carry it with you to the big leagues if you make it that far in your career.
The Rawlings R9 Series, on the other hand, is a good option if you’re looking for a beginner glove that won’t break the bank. Even though it is a cheap glove, it boasts many outstanding features. The Rawlings R9 has been used by some of the top high school softball players I’ve seen. So, are you ready to take command of the field? You’re well aware of your responsibilities. Cheers!