How to Choose a Softball Catcher’s Mitt

Contents show

Catcher’s mitts are available in various configurations, allowing you to tailor your equipment for success completely. Find out more about this critical tool for dominating behind the plate in this article.
A keen observational ability. A powerful arm. Legs that move quickly. Mind that is sharp and analytical.
All of these characteristics are necessary for a successful catcher. You have a clear view of the whole field from your position, and you can influence the pace of your team’s defense at critical periods.
It is a physically demanding job. Because it is your most potent tool, selecting a mitt tailored to your unique requirements is critical to your success. The correct glove may help you gain confidence, allowing you to make better, more reflexive plays as a result.

Our Top 3 Picks


#Top 1
Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove - Field Master - Baseball and Softball Mitt
Amazon.com
Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove - Field Master - Baseball and...
$23.99
#Top 2
Rawlings Liberty Advanced Softball Glove Series, 34
Amazon.com
Rawlings Liberty Advanced Softball Glove Series, 34
$359.99
#Top 3
Crazy Catcher Softball Lovers Bat Ball Baseball Women T-Shirt
Amazon.com
Crazy Catcher Softball Lovers Bat Ball Baseball Women T-Shirt
$19.95

Top 10 Best Softball Catchers Mitt For Dads

1
Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove - Field Master - Baseball and Softball Mitt
Best choice
Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove - Field Master - Baseball and Softball Mitt
Check Price Amazon.com
9.9
2
Rawlings Liberty Advanced Softball Glove Series, 34
Recommended
Rawlings Liberty Advanced Softball Glove Series, 34
Check Price Amazon.com
9.7
3
Crazy Catcher Softball Lovers Bat Ball Baseball Women T-Shirt
High quality
Crazy Catcher Softball Lovers Bat Ball Baseball Women T-Shirt
Check Price Amazon.com
9.4
4
MacGregor Jr Series Catchers Mitt - RHT (EA)
MacGregor Jr Series Catchers Mitt - RHT (EA)
Check Price Amazon.com
8.9
5
Wilson Sporting Goods "A360 Baseball cm 31.5"" - Right Hand Throw,31.5"",Black, Large (WBW100190315)
Wilson Sporting Goods "A360 Baseball cm 31.5"" - Right Hand Throw,31.5"",Black, Large (WBW100190315)
Check Price Amazon.com
8.2
6
PRECISION IMPACT Softhands Foam Baseball Fielding Training Glove (2-Pack)
PRECISION IMPACT Softhands Foam Baseball Fielding Training Glove (2-Pack)
Check Price Amazon.com
8
7
Rawlings Player Preferred Baseball Catcher's Mitt, Regular, 1-Piece Solid Web, 33 Inch
Rawlings Player Preferred Baseball Catcher's Mitt, Regular, 1-Piece Solid Web, 33 Inch
Check Price Amazon.com
7.9
8
Mizuno GPSL1250F3 Prospect Select Series Fastpitch Softball Glove 12.5", Right Hand Throw, BLACK
Mizuno GPSL1250F3 Prospect Select Series Fastpitch Softball Glove 12.5", Right Hand Throw, BLACK
Check Price Amazon.com
7.7
9
Franklin Sports Softball Glove - Left and Right Handed Softball Fielding Glove - Windmill Fastpitch Pro Series - Adult and Youth Fielding Glove - 12 Inch Right Hand Throw - Pink
Franklin Sports Softball Glove - Left and Right Handed Softball Fielding Glove - Windmill...
Check Price Amazon.com
7.5
10
Rawlings Shut Out Series Youth Softball Catchers Glove, 32.5 inch, Mod Pro H Web, Right Hand Throw
Rawlings Shut Out Series Youth Softball Catchers Glove, 32.5 inch, Mod Pro H Web, Right Hand Throw
Check Price Amazon.com
7.5

Every Products Detail of Best Softball Catchers Mitt For Dads

Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove - Field Master - Baseball and Softball Mitt

Franklin Sports Baseball and Softball Glove - Field Master - Baseball and Softball Mitt

Important Features of The Product:

  • EASY BREAK IN: The soft synthetic leather material is lightweight and responsive making the glove easy and quick to break in so it will be game-ready in no time for baseball, softball, or teeball
  • CONTOUR FIT SYSTEM: Customizable thumb-adjustment technology engineered to expand or tighten to help achieve the perfect snug fit to accommodate all players
  • DURABLILITY: Crafted of a thick, premium synthetic leather designed to mimic the performance and durability of a true leather mitt without the long break-in period
  • HAND FORMED POCKET: The hand formed pocket provides maximum comfort and responsive feel for making scoops and catches without drops
  • NOTE: Left Hand Throw glove = worn on right hand to throw with left; Right Hand Throw = glove worn on left hand to throw with right

Rawlings Liberty Advanced Softball Glove Series, 34

Rawlings Liberty Advanced Softball Glove Series, 34

Important Features of The Product:

  • Modified Pro H Web Is Similar to the Pro H Web, but Modified for Softball Glove Pattern
  • Balanced Patterns and Adjusted Hand Openings for Improved Fit Control
  • Poron XRD palm and index finger pads significantly reduce ball impact for greater protection
  • Game-ready feel with full-grain oil treated shell leather
  • Custom fit, Adjustable, non-slip pull strap
  • Right Hand Throw = Left Hand Glove, Left Hand Throw = Right Hand Glove
  • Right Hand Orientation = Right Hand Throw / Left Hand Orientation = Left Hand Throw

Crazy Catcher Softball Lovers Bat Ball Baseball Women T-Shirt

Crazy Catcher Softball Lovers Bat Ball Baseball Women T-Shirt

Important Features of The Product:

  • This Crazy Catcher graphic shows a glove catching a ball. It says I'm The Crazy Catcher They Warned You About. An awesome idea for girls who play this outdoor game as a catcher, pitcher, fielder, baseman or batter and collects jerseys of this sport.
  • This design is perfect for female softball fans who love playing this competitive bat and ball game similar to baseball. A gameday apparel while watching your favorite softball players pitch and hit home runs together with your family and friends
  • Lightweight, Classic fit, Double-needle sleeve and bottom hem

MacGregor Jr Series Catchers Mitt - RHT (EA)

MacGregor Jr Series Catchers Mitt - RHT (EA)

Important Features of The Product:

  • Made in China
  • Package dimension :27.94 cm x 20.32 cm x 15.24 cm
  • Product type : SPORT MITT
  • Package weight : 0.65 lbs

Wilson Sporting Goods "A360 Baseball cm 31.5"" - Right Hand Throw,31.5"",Black, Large (WBW100190315)

Wilson Sporting Goods "A360 Baseball cm 31.5"" - Right Hand Throw,31.5"",Black, Large (WBW100190315)

Important Features of The Product:

  • 31.5"
  • Half Moon Web
  • CarbonLite Shell helps reduce the weight without sacrificing durability
  • Black/Grey leather in a timeless look
  • Velcro design for easy in-game adjustments

PRECISION IMPACT Softhands Foam Baseball Fielding Training Glove (2-Pack)

PRECISION IMPACT Softhands Foam Baseball Fielding Training Glove (2-Pack)

Important Features of The Product:

  • ULTIMATE FIELDING: If you like to train hard and get satisfaction out of seeing your skills improve, then you'll enjoy training with a pancake training glove. No other fielding training tool will improve your fielding as quickly as this!
  • PILLOWY SOFT HANDS: By creating a much more difficult fielding situation via a flat glove, you will be forced to adapt and improve your energy transference. Your coach will wonder how your hands got so pillowy soft!
  • VALUE: Comes with two gloves so you can practice the same techniques with your partner. Train together and coach each other!
  • TIGHT FITTING DESIGN: Finger straps are nice and short so that the glove doesn't fall off like with other foam training gloves.
  • 100% SATISFACTION GUARANTEE: Our training equipment comes with a 100% Satisfaction Guarantee. Our customer service is dedicated to addressing any product/service issues and is committed to delivering a 5 star experience for all buyers. If you're not happy with our product, simply return it for a full refund. You really have nothing to lose!

Rawlings Player Preferred Baseball Catcher's Mitt, Regular, 1-Piece Solid Web, 33 Inch

Rawlings Player Preferred Baseball Catcher's Mitt, Regular, 1-Piece Solid Web, 33 Inch

Important Features of The Product:

  • 33 inch baseball catcher's mitt great for recreational baseball and Softball games
  • Zero Shock palm padding for increased impact Protection while catching
  • Quick and Easy break in for a game Ready feel
  • Conventional back for a secure fit
  • 1 piece solid web Designed for catchers
  • Right Hand Throw = Left Hand Glove, Left Hand Throw = Right Hand Glove
  • Right Hand Orientation = Right Hand Throw / Left Hand Orientation = Left Hand Throw

Mizuno GPSL1250F3 Prospect Select Series Fastpitch Softball Glove 12.5", Right Hand Throw, BLACK

Mizuno GPSL1250F3 Prospect Select Series Fastpitch Softball Glove 12.5", Right Hand Throw, BLACK

Important Features of The Product:

  • Gender engineered: Mizuno engineering philosophy to maximize performance by tailoring products to meet the needs of the female athlete
  • Full grain leather shell: for great durability. Youth Ages : 10-12
  • Mzo lining: disperses perspiration away from the skin.
  • Polyurethane power lock: the simplest and most secure fit Available with PU pull tab.
  • Thumb cut: thumb area hinge to increases flexibility in order to make closing the glove easier.
  • Less 2 Lacing: Removes the last 2 lace loops on the web to increase flexibility along the closing axis.
  • Parashock Palm Pad: Mizuno's exclusive palm pad absorbs the shock of repeated use providing outstanding protection and ideal comfort
  • PowerClose Technology: Makes catching easy for younger players.

Franklin Sports Softball Glove - Left and Right Handed Softball Fielding Glove - Windmill Fastpitch Pro Series - Adult and Youth Fielding Glove - 12 Inch Right Hand Throw - Pink

Franklin Sports Softball Glove - Left and Right Handed Softball Fielding Glove - Windmill Fastpitch Pro Series - Adult and Youth Fielding Glove - 12 Inch Right Hand Throw - Pink

Important Features of The Product:

  • LIGHTWEIGHT MESH DESIGN: Constructed from lightweight technical mesh, this glove gives maximum comfort and helps facilitate quick hands out in the field
  • ADJUSTABLE WRIST: Designed with an adjustable wrist closure to ensure a comfortable customized fit for all players
  • SOFT POCKET: The soft pocket material is designed for a quick, easy break in process and provides a dynamic, responsive feel when catching the ball
  • GREAT FOR YOUNG PLAYERS: Adjustable sizing and comfortable fit make this glove perfect for Softball players of all ages
  • NOTE: Left Hand Thrower glove, worn on right hand to throw with left, Right Hand Throw equals to glove worn on left hand to throw with right

Rawlings Shut Out Series Youth Softball Catchers Glove, 32.5 inch, Mod Pro H Web, Right Hand Throw

Rawlings Shut Out Series Youth Softball Catchers Glove, 32.5 inch, Mod Pro H Web, Right Hand Throw

Important Features of The Product:

  • DESIGNED FOR CATCHERS this 32.5 inch fastpitch softball glove with Pro H web design provides the ultimate level of comfort and protection to allow catchers to stop every ball at the plate
  • FOR SELECT PLAYERS BETWEEN 8 - 14 YEARS OLD
  • SPECIFICALLY DESIGNED FOR THE HAND SIZE OF THE FEMALE ATHLETE this glove provides the ultimate level of comfort and control
  • ADJUSTABLE VELCRO STRAP allows for custom fit on any female hand size
  • FULL-GRAN LEATHER for enhanced durability and ZERO SHOCK PALM padding for enhanced impact protection
  • 80% FACTORY 20% PLAYER BREAK-IN makes this glove playable right out of the box with minimal break-in needed
  • RIGHT HAND THROW (Glove goes on left hand)
  • Right Hand Orientation = Right Hand Throw Left Hand Orientation = Left Hand Throw

Keep the following in mind when you choose:

GLOVES VS. MITT

Although the words “glove” and “mitt” are sometimes used interchangeably in softball, there is a definite — and significant — distinction between catchers and their equipment. 
Separate finger pockets are found on a glove (such as a winter glove), providing increased flexibility, variety, and speed while playing sports. On the other hand, a catcher’s mitt is meant to keep your fingers closer together, sacrificing unneeded mobility for more protection. In terms of security, we are talking about both the physical safety of things and the psychological security of making sure you catch the ball.
Mitts are complicated, with many design alternatives available for their manufacturing. When making your final selection, keep the following factors in mind:

WEBBING

Another significant distinction between baseball and softball catcher’s gloves is that, although baseball mitts nearly exclusively have closed webbing, softball mitts almost always have open webbing, which is more prevalent in baseball. This design compromises some support, but since softball mitts are typically bigger than baseball mitts, the increased visibility proportional to the size of the ball necessitates this compromise.  

BACK

In the past, catcher’s mitts had closed backs, which helped improve your wrist’s support. However, this may not be vital for your performance nowadays. Increased mobility is made possible by an open back, defined by a gap between the wrist strap and the top half of the glove. Some variants also incorporate an external finger hole on the back of the glove, which helps to increase mobility and control even more. A suitable balance between mobility and security should be considered while making your choice.

PADDING

Padding should be avoided at all costs by players. A glove with an excessive amount of it will not have enough space to accommodate the giant ball. On the other hand, a larger ball puts more significant pressure on a larger surface area of your hand, necessitating more padding to protect your hand.
When making your selection, make sure that the product is labeled as being particularly for softball. By using thinner cushioning, these models consider the demand for the more excellent room while maintaining enough protection.

MATERIALS

Another one of those personal decisions is whether or not to use a leather model. Other factors to consider include how much time you want to spend breaking in your glove and how long you want your glove to endure.
Less costly leathers like synthetics and pigskin break in rapidly, but they may only last one season (or less, if you’re playing in an elite league) before needing to be replaced. In most cases, they’re a decent alternative for younger athletes or players who haven’t completely committed to numerous seasons.
Full-grain or steer hide leathers take considerably longer to break in — months, in most cases — and maybe much more expensive, but they will last much longer and not wear as rapidly. As a result, if you want to continue playing for several years, the expense may be justified in the long term. However, you will need to purchase them a few months in advance to break them in during practice sessions. Some models are sent partly “factory broken,” allowing the break-in process to be completed more quickly.

SIZING 

Remember that catcher’s mitts are measured by their diameter rather than their length. Players aged 12 and under should search for catcher’s mitts about 32.5 inches in circumference. In comparison, players ages 13 and above should go for gloves that are around 33 or 34 inches in circumference so that you can obtain a full enough pocket for the giant ball.
While it is true that bigger is better in softball, bear in mind that a larger glove will reduce your visibility and agility, so be mindful of this while choosing your mitt. There are specific alternatives available to compensate for the reduced vision and skill, which you may learn more about further down in this section.
When looking for the ideal mitt, keep in mind that you should play to your skills and limitations. Do you need a bit greater freedom of movement? Find a glove with a rear that can be opened. Is Will having a plan help you improve your game? Choosing a model with thicker cushioning is a good idea.
Customization is made possible via a diverse variety of possibilities. Improve your performance by selecting a catcher’s mitt that will make you feel comfortable and confident behind the plate.

People also ask

How do you pick a softball catcher’s mitt?

SIZING. Remember that catcher’s mitts are measured by their diameter rather than their length. Players aged 12 and under should search for catcher’s mitts about 32.5 inches in circumference. In comparison, players ages 13 and above should go for gloves that are around 33 or 34 inches in circumference so that you can obtain a full enough pocket for the giant ball.

Who is the best softball catcher?

Our picks for the five most famous Softball catchers of all time are:

  • Suzy Brazney.
  • Nancy Ito.
  • Stacey Nuveman.
  • Marilyn Rau.
  • Dot Wilkinson.

What catcher’s mitt did Johnny Bench use?

Bench spent the rest of his career at first or third base, save for the 1983 season, where he played first. The ” Deep Well, ” a professional model catcher’s glove from Rawlings, “Deep Well” performs well in-game situations.

What size glove does Anthony Rizzo use?

In addition to Rizzo’s design, this 12.75-inch first base glove from Heart of the Hide also has deer-tanned palm lining, a thermoformed wrist liner, and extra-long padding on the thumb sleeve.

What is the fastest way to break in a softball catcher’s mitt?

It all starts with how you break it in.

Place it in the oven and “cook” it for a few minutes.
Vaseline should be applied liberally.
Shaving cream should be applied to it.
To “steam” your glove, you must first visit a sports goods retailer.
Please put it in the microwave for a few seconds.
Putting it beneath your mattress and sleeping on it is a popular choice.
Oils should be applied to the whole pocket.
And a few more outlandish notions!

Is there a catcher’s mitt for softball?

You may act as a human backstop with the proper softball catcher’s glove.
A softball catcher’s glove, in addition to cleats and safety equipment, is an absolute must-have piece of equipment for everyone who takes on the problematic position.